KEEPING THE FAITH - In The News
September 23, 2009

Dissecting President Obama’s Global Warming Speech
from The Heritage Foundation
by Nick Loris

This morning, President Obama delivered his climate change speech at a United Nations Summit on Climate Change. Stressing the need for urgent action, Obama told the Assembly that the United States, in his first eight months as President, is becoming a leader in the war against a warming planet.

Obama began his speech by declaring that the time to act is now:

That so many of us are here today is a recognition that the threat from climate change is serious, it is urgent, and it is growing. Our generation’s response to this challenge will be judged by history, for if we fail to meet it – boldly, swiftly, and together – we risk consigning future generations to an irreversible catastrophe.”

The earth’s average temperature has been increasing and decreasing for centuries, and many point to the recent period of warming as evidence of a dangerous human-induced warming. But temperatures have risen and fallen many times before that. The Medieval Warm Period (c. 1100-1450) and earlier periods were likely as warm or warmer than the present. The earth was cooling as recently as the period from the 1940s to the 1970s, giving rise to fears of a coming ice age.

Obama went on to say:

No nation, however large or small, wealthy or poor, can escape the impact of climate change. Rising sea levels threaten every coastline. More powerful storms and floods threaten every continent. More frequent drought and crop failures breed hunger and conflict in places where hunger and conflict already thrive. On shrinking islands, families are already being forced to flee their homes as climate refugees. The security and stability of each nation and all peoples – our prosperity, our health, our safety – are in jeopardy. And the time we have to reverse this tide is running out.”

Catastrophic predictions are poorly supported by evidence and often greatly exaggerated by the likes of Al Gore and other alarmists. But even “The U.N. Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), which Gore considers to be the gold standard of consensus science, projects an increase of 7 to 23 inches over the next century. The lower end of that range is about what has occurred — without serious consequences — over the last two centuries.”

Moreover, natural disasters are just that: natural. Changing the weather to prevent hurricanes and other natural disasters is currently impossible, but adapting to them is not. For instance, countries and states have shown this by better preparing for hurricanes—building better levees, rebuilding sand dunes and upgrading building codes to withstand damage. Adaptation to climate change, whether warming or cooling, will prove to be prudent; changing the weather through measures like cap and trade will not be.

Obama next turned his attention to what the United States is doing to combat climate change:

And I am proud to say that the United States has done more to promote clean energy and reduce carbon pollution in the last eight months than at any other time in our history. We’re making our government’s largest ever investment in renewable energy – an investment aimed at doubling the generating capacity from wind and other renewable resources in three years. Across America, entrepreneurs are constructing wind turbines and solar panels and batteries for hybrid cars with the help of loan guarantees and tax credits – projects that are creating new jobs and new industries. We’re investing billions to cut energy waste in our homes, buildings, and appliances – helping American families save money on energy bills in the process. “

Ah, so there is such a thing as a free lunch.

No, there’s not. These renewable energy investments (read: subsidies) not only cost the American taxpayer but will also result in higher electricity bills since they cannot compete in the market without said investments. For many years, wind energy has been the beneficiary of generous tax credits and subsidies, but it still provides less than 2 percent of America’s electricity. It is unreliable and will be costly ($80 billion) to build transmission lines to bring wind from where it is produced to where it is needed.

President Obama did mention getting rid of one subsidy: “Later this week, I will work with my colleagues at the G20 to phase out fossil fuel subsidies so that we can better address our climate challenge.” This is commendable, but if the President wants a sound energy policy that will benefit electricity consumers, he should focus on removing all subsidies from the market. Any subsidy, whatever the source of energy or product, distorts normal market forces and encourages government dependence. By subsidizing a portion of the actual cost of a project through a loan guarantee, the government is actually distorting the allocation of resources by directing capital away from a more competitive project. Allowing all energy sources to compete absent of subsidies, mandates or tax credits will benefit consumers most.

Speaking about the mother-of-all environmental policies, cap and trade, Obama remarked:

“Most importantly, the House of Representatives passed an energy and climate bill in June that would finally make clean energy the profitable kind of energy for American businesses and dramatically reduce greenhouse gas emissions. One committee has already acted on this bill in the Senate and I look forward to engaging with others as we move forward.”

The Heritage Foundation hosted 6 representatives from organizations, including three government agencies, that modeled the economic impact of cap and trade, and not one projected a net increase in income or employment from cap and trade. It was all about how big the losses would be. And the economic pain, no matter how big or small, would all be for no environmental gain as the current cap and trade bill would reduce global temperatures by only a fraction of a degree. The event can be found here.

The rest of the president’s talk focused on working with other nations to combat climate change:

Because no one nation can meet this challenge alone, the United States has also engaged more allies and partners in finding a solution than ever before. In April, we convened the first of what have now been six meetings of the Major Economies Forum on Energy and Climate here in the United States. In Trinidad, I proposed an Energy and Climate Partnership for the Americas. We’ve worked through the World Bank to promote renewable energy projects and technologies in the developing world.

We also cannot allow the old divisions that have characterized the climate debate for so many years to block our progress. Yes, the developed nations that caused much of the damage to our climate over the last century still have a responsibility to lead. But those rapidly-growing developing nations that will produce nearly all the growth in global carbon emissions in the decades ahead must do their part as well. Some of these nations have already made great strides with the development and deployment of clean energy. Still, they will need to commit to strong measures at home and agree to stand behind those commitments just as the developed nations must stand behind their own. We cannot meet this challenge unless all the largest emitters of greenhouse gas pollution act together. There is no other way.”

In a case of international cooperation, India, China and the rest of the developing world would likely have to revert to emission output levels that are pure fantasy. On a per-capita basis, China would backtrack to about one 10th of what the United States emitted in 2000. India and most of the developing world would have to drop to even lower levels. This is a de-developing strategy which no country will or should adopt. These countries should focus on getting electricity to all of their citizens before they worry about cutting carbon emissions.

Technology sharing, on the other hand, has merit. Opening up global markets can act as a means to transfer clean technologies and promote economic growth that will better enable these countries to adapt to climate change, if necessary. Capping carbon dioxide and transferring money from one government to another will do nothing to raise living standards and a lot to lower them.

In his concluding sentence, President Obama stressed that we should work to leave the world one “that is worthy of our children.” But the suggested policies will leave us with lower economic growth, less income, higher unemployment, and more personal debt for energy that will be more expensive. It will reduce opportunity for growth all over the world. Our children should be more fearful of global warming policies than global warming itself.

Thank you for Keeping The Faith,
Sadie Fields

Mark Your Calendar! 2010 FAITH - FAMILY - FREEDOM KICKOFF! Saturday, February 6, 2010 Riverwood High School Auditorium 5900 Heards Drive, N.W. Atlanta, GA 30328 Advance tickets $30 per person - $10 children under 12 and that includes lunch by Williamson Bros. BBQ! Purchase advance tickets here. Tickets will be available at door $35 per person. read more info

 

Jimmy Carter - His Quest for Relevance Sept 17, 2009

Our Tragedy if the Commons Sept 9, 2009

Today's Calamity: Don't Forget About Renewable Energy Mandates Sept 1, 2009

FINALLY, Change We Can Believe In Aug 19, 2009

Obama’s Heath Care “Reform” Includes Benefits for Illegal Immigrants Aug 6, 2009

Take Two Aspirin And Call Me When Your Cancer is Stage 4 July 23, 2009

The Road to Single Payer Goes Through the Public Plan June 25, 2009

Justice, Fairness & The Supreme Court June 8, 2009

Obama's History Lesson - Outreach or Overreach? June 5, 2009

Obama's 'Gay Pride Month' Proclamation June 3, 2009

Sotomayor in Her Own Words March 27, 2009

On the Road to Socialism? We've Arrived! March 4, 2009

Please define innocent, Mr. President February 5, 2009

Military Judge Refuses to Halt Trial of USS Cole Bombing Suspect January 30, 2009

Ignorance is bliss - Knowledge equals responsibility January 28, 2009

Obama launches his own version of "The Killing Fields" January 24, 2009

Republicans need Shareholder Revolt - Commentary by Star Parker January 12, 2009

Stop this Bad Dream! -by Ann Coulter December 30, 2008

Merry Christmas to ALL! December 24, 2008

Marching As to War November 13, 2008

Contrast of Where McCain-Obama Stand on Your Money November 3, 2008

McGuire Best Pick for Court of Appeals October 29, 2008

Obama's First 100 Days October 28, 2008

COUNTDOWN To November 4th October 18, 2008

'Teachable Moments' San Francisco-style October 14, 2008

Day of Reckoning September 27, 2008

A Catholic Case Against Barack August 12, 2008

Who is Louis Farrakhan? March 7, 2008

Purchase Tickets for our 2008 Faith, Family & Freedom Kickoff Jan 15, 2008

Ohio Choose Life Inc. Raises Over $100,000 Dec 6, 2007

Sumter Regional Hospital needs Your Help Nov 26, 2007

Law of the Sea Treaty (LOST) Update Nov 1, 2007

Update on Immigration Reform & U.S. Supreme Court Sides with Free Speech June 27, 2007

The Regime Against the Nation June 14, 2007

Too Bad - President Bush Has Torn The Conservative Coalition Asunder June 5, 2007

Public Wants Illegals to Go Home May 22, 2007

Immigration Reform May 21, 2007

Pre-order Choose Life Tags January 8, 2007

Some Questions for Gov. Romney January 2, 2007

Merry Christmas and Happy New Year to All! December 25, 2006

The Meaning of the Midterms November 8, 2006

Why Is Bush So Stubborn? May 31, 2006

The Solution to the Immigration Crisis - Nothing for Nothing April 10, 2006

Tony Blankley on Senate Arrogance March 29, 2006

Bill to Kill 'Roe' signed into Law March 6, 2006

Body Worlds and the Culture of Death February 23, 2006

Please Join Us for a Discussion on Illegal Immigrants February 7, 2006

Alito Parts with Conservatives on Execution February 2, 2006

Our 2006 Families & Freedom Kickoff was another exciting event! January 23, 2006

Christian Coalition of Georgia Supports the "Holiday Free Speech Act" December 10, 2005

Fighting for Christmas By Rabbi Daniel Lapin December 1, 2005

FIRST PERSON: Christmas Under Fire -- and the Return of the Grinch By Ralph Baker from AgapePress November 22, 2005

Federalist Society Speech By Karl Rove, Deputy Chief of Staff November 10, 2005

Dangerous caution October 29, 200

Considered, confirmed originalism is not elitism October 25, 2005

American Citizenship Is Precious October 12, 2005

Attorney: School Mental health Screenings Violate Students' Privacy, Parents' Rights September 23, 2005

"Under God' Undermined ... Again September 15, 2005

Constitutional Myths and Realities August 23, 2005

Mass. Dad's Parental Rights Fight Polarizes Lexington August 5, 2005

Support the Fair Tax August 1, 2005

Chambliss and Isakson's Statements on Nomination of Judge John Roberts to the U.S. Supreme Court July 20, 2005

What becomes of the brokenhearted? The Oregonian - July 14, 2005

Senate Passes Isakson Amendment July 12, 2005

Their Will Be Done July 5, 2005

Sandra Day O'Connor Resigns July 1, 2005

Christians Ought To Do More In This Debate June 12, 2005

Why I'm Rooting for the Religious Right May 5, 2005